- Loki wrote:
- Anarchism is political atheism. What do I mean when I say that?
Anarchism is the absence of belief in politics and government like atheism is the absence of belief in religion.
I think you need to be careful that you don't clump all anarchism into one "catch-all" philosophy. What I mean is that some anarchism tends to be totally individualistic, whereas others are collectivist.
It tends to be the belief that the state is unnecessary, not the absence of belief in politics as such. Therefore this statement seems incorrect to me.
I think it would be more accurate to say that anarchism is political humanism: The state/church/divine power is no longer regarded as necessary, instead the power comes from within.
And yes, I have a problem with humanists claiming to be atheist. They may reject the concept of divinity of nature/universe but they replace it with divinity of reason and Human Ideals.
Perhaps anarchism could be better described as an autotheism... like buddhism.
- Quote :
Anarchism is apolitical in that it views politics and government as being irrelevant in the position of individuals gaining independence for themselves in a sustainable manner.
I disagree that anarchism is apolitical. It is a political position. Any engagement between two individuals is political, and always has some economic or individual interest behind it. The philosophy behind anarchism is political at its heart.
- Quote :
Where government supporters offer political and government solutions to everything anarchists instead offer individual solutions to people.
You actually seem to be clumping anarchism and right-wing politics into one group - what you say could be true of liberal capitalists as well as leftist anarchists. The two are not necessarily the same.
- Quote :
Government is pro institutionalism where anarchists are anti institutionalism.
This is correct.